Skip to main content

Yamaha FZ25 vs TVS Apache RTR 200 vs KTM Duke 200: Specifications comparison

              At the Yamaha FZ25’s launch event, Yamaha officials made it clear that the motorcycle is targeted more at current FZ-S customers looking for an upgrade rather than customers entering the segment for the first time. That might as well be the case, because the FZ25 is up against mighty stiff competition which includes the homegrown TVS Apache RTR 200, the aggressive KTM Duke 200 and the soon-to-be-relaunched Bajaj Pulsar 200NS. And with intent of focusing on hard fact, we will peg, on paper, the new Yamaha against its formidable TVS and KTM rivals. 


The heart of the matter
At the crux of every debate about which bike is better is its performance, especially in the case of these bikes because they belong to the first tier of the performance motorcycles segment.
The Yamaha FZ25 is powered by a 249cc air-cooled engine with two valves and SOHC; the TVS Apache RTR 200 by an 197.75cc air- and oil-cooled engine with four valves; and the KTM Duke 200 with a 199.5cc, liquid-cooled engine with four valves and DOHC. All three engines are single-cylinder units.

The FZ25 may have the largest engine of the lot, but this, unfortunately, does not translate to the highest power figure. The FZ25 produces 20.9hp at 8,000rpm, while the smaller-engined Apache RTR 200 produces 20.05hp at 8,500rpm and the Duke 200 a whopping 25hp at 10,000rpm. It does, however, produce most peak torque of the three at 20Nm, though the Duke 200 (19Nm) and Apache RTR 200 (18Nm) are not far behind.

The FZ25 does not even get a weight advantage. At 148kg, it weighs the same as the Apache RTR 200 and significantly more than the 130-odd kg Duke 200.
On paper, then, the FZ25 does not make a compelling case for itself against its chief rivals.

Chassis and Suspension
The FZ25 is built on a diamond frame, the Apache RTR 200 on a double-cradle split frame and the Duke 200 on a steel trellis frame. The Duke 200’s steel trellis frame gives it a substantial weight-saving advantage, though all three are more or less on par in terms of chassis quality.
The FZ25 and Apache RTR 200 both ride on telescopic forks up front and a monoshock at the back. While the Duke 200 too gets a rear monoshock, it has an upper hand over the two in terms of the front suspension set-up – it gets upside-down telescopic forks.

The FZ25’s brakes rack up poorly against the competition on paper. While it makes do with a 282mm disc in the front and 220mm disc round the back, the Apache RTR 200 gets 270mm and 240mm petal-type discs at the front and rear, and the Duke 200 enjoys 300mm and 230mm discs respectively.
In terms of dimensions that matter, the Apache RTR 200 has the shortest wheelbase at 1,353mm, followed by the FZ25 at 1,360mm and Duke 200 at 1,367mm. The FZ25 offers the lowest ride height at 795mm, followed by the Apache RTR 200 at 800mm and Duke 200 at 810mm.

Equipment

The FZ25 gets LED headlights and tail-lights, which the other two miss out now. All three motorcycles get a fully digital instrument panel. The Apache RTR 200, additionally, gets ABS and daytime running lights
.
Price
The big differentiator between the three motorcycles is the price. At Rs 93,725, the Apache RTR 200 easily represents most value for money. The Yamaha FZ25 at Rs 1,19,500 seems a tad overpriced. The Duke 200 priced Rs 1,44,000 is substantially more expensive than the other two, but then again, it offers far better performance too. In fact, in terms of performance and price, the Duke 200 is a bit of an outlier here. (All prices ex-showroom, Delhi).

Yamaha FZ25TVS Apache RTR 200KTM Duke 200
Engine249cc, air-cooled197.75cc, air- and oil-cooled199.5cc, liquid-cooled
Power20.9hp at 8000rpm20.05hp at 8500rpm25hp at 10,000rpm
Gearbox5-speed5-speed6-speed
Dimensions (LxWxH)2015x770x1075mm2050x790x1105mm2002x873x1274mm
Wheelbase1360mm1353mm1367mm
Ride Height795mm800mm810mm
Front SuspensionTelescopic forksTelescopic forksUpside-down telescopic forks
Rear SuspensionMonoshockMonoshockMonoshock
Front Brake Disc282mm round270mm petal300mm round
Rear Brake Disc220mm round240mm petal230mm round
ABSNoYesNo
Tyres (F/R)100/80-17 (F)/
140/70-17 (R)		90/90-17 (F)/
130/70-17 (R)		110/70- 17 (F)/
150/60- 17 (R)
Price (ex-showroom, Delhi)Rs 1.19,500Rs 93,725Rs 1,44,000

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

2018 Lamborghini Urus India review, test drive

             On first introduction, it’s a recipe for intimidation. It’s claimed to be the fastest SUV in the world (0-100kph in 3.6sec and a top speed of 305kph puts it nearly in supercar territory), and it’s made by Lamborghini – creator of some of the most savage vehicles on the market. Things – as with any Lamborghini, for that matter – would be a lot less daunting if we were driving on a smooth European country road, a wide motorway, or even a race track. But today we’re driving the Urus on a narrow  ghat  road, as well as through some heavy Pune traffic. Perhaps the intention was to demonstrate that this is the first Lamborghini ever to go on sale in India that truly works in our conditions – but still, I doubt they accounted for rush hour. It’s requisitely mad to look at, employing as many ‘sporty’ design tropes to an SUV body style as possible – the only thing missing is a massive wing on the back; and somehow, it works. It’s ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Rolls Royce Cullinan SUV in the works

Rolls Royce has released the first pictures of its Cullinan SUV prototype. The company has said that only the length of the prototype gives clues about the production. The entire car is an engineering mock-up to test the new all-wheel drive transmission and suspension. The prototype, based on a shortened Phantom II, is set for road testing from the second week of April. The company has said that it would “assist Rolls Royce engineers in developing a final suspension system that will deliver the brand's hallmark 'magic carpet' ride not only on the road, but off-road too”. Rolls Royce CEO Torsten Muller-Ötvös had, some time back, confirmed to our sister publication Autocar UK, that the company was developing an all-new four-wheel drive high-bodied Rolls Royce. He had, however, avoided using the word ‘SUV’. The new Rolls Royce is expected to shatter existing price and size ceilings for a SUV, but as per the brand's design boss Giles Taylor, the SUV will be po...
Post a Comment
Read more

Honda City facelift India launch on February 14

                       Honda will launch the refreshed City sedan in the Indian market on February 14, 2017. The carmaker has started accepting bookings for the updated sedan with the booking amount set at Rs 21,000.  The Honda City had long been the best seller in the segment, though in recent months the Maruti Ciaz has risen to the challenge, outselling the City in certain months last year. And with rivals such as Skoda having recently given the Rapid a facelift, and Volkswagen’s near constant updates to the Vento, Honda looks to refresh interest in the City with a facelifted model. Here’s what you can expect from the updated Honda City in India. 1. It sports cosmetic changes: The updated City’s front now gets a Civic-like nose and chin, along with a chrome band running across the grille and spilling over the headlights on both sides. The headlights' shape has been mildly tweaked and now houses LED daytime runn...
Post a Comment
Read more